Concert Reviews
THREE SPIRES
CONCERT REVIEW: VAUGHAN WILLIAM, RUTTER, BERNSTEIN, PARRY
After a run of concerts largely dominated by Bach, Mozart
and Handel, it was good to see the Three Spires returning to more contemporary
repertoire for their concert on July 6th. No commissions or works by living
composers admittedly, but still an entire evening of 20th century
music. And while this was not repertoire that would have devotees of the Avant Garde
or experimentalist traditions rushing to buy tickets, it did provide an
opportunity to hear mainstream works in rarely heard arrangements. In a break
with the norm, the resident orchestra was whittled down to a chamber ensemble
comprising flute, oboe, cello, harp, organ and percussion.
The Five Mystical Songs by Vaughan Williams is more often
heard either with full orchestral or solo organ accompaniment, and this arrangement
by the composer for harp, timpani and organ provided a fascinating perspective
on an early work, traces of the first symphony bursting forth in the choral interjections
and organ/percussion swells. Conductor James Anderson-Besant shaped the work
with authority and had doubtless worked the singers hard to bring out the best
they had to offer. Baritone Alex Bower-Brown provided a thoroughly convincing rendition
with excellent projection and subtle interpretation. The organ sounded at once powerful
and ethereal – set back behind and above the choir but surging forward and
outward with each crescendo. Choir entries were judiciously placed, and if the
lower voices did struggle at times with their high notes, the sound was
generally secure and rewarding. The closing passages of ‘Love Bade Me Welcome’
proved especially moving (and apposite), with the choir remaining seated as
they intoned ‘You must sit down, says Love, and taste my meat: So I did sit and
eat.’
The evening’s first half concluded with a setting of the Requiem
mass by John Rutter. Having heard the same group perform his Gloria a few years
ago, I was expecting a similar diet of easy-listening. Instead, the work opens
with dark, brooding bass lines carving out a climbing chromatic figure, not unlike
the uncompromising opening of Lutosławski’s 4th
symphony and leading to a choir entry almost certainly modelled on Britten’s
War Requiem. True, the more accessible Rutter style soon establishes itself, but
the sugar is tempered by the harder edges of the pared down instrumental forces
(the arrangement is the composer’s own). Excellent performances here from
Barbara Degener (cello), James Robinson (tuned percussion), Gabriella dall’Olio
(harp), Tamsin Robinson (oboe) and Karen Green (flute), while soprano soloist
Katherine Gregory was magnificent, her voice balancing expressivity with
clarity, projection and precision.
Audiences familiar with Leonard Bernstein’s popular Jazzy
stage works like ‘On The Town’ or ‘West Side Story’, may not have anticipated
the seriousness, rigour and challenges of the work that began the second half. Firstly,
The Chichester Psalms are sung entirely in Hebrew, secondly, the harmonic
language is taught, the part writing fiendishly difficult (especially for the
male voices) and thirdly, the arrangement (Bernstein’s own) for harp, organ and
percussion strips back his usual lavish colours to their bare essentials.
Though everyone clearly threw everything they had into this
work, it was perhaps not quite ready for performance. Complex passages at times
lacked a degree of rhythmic precision, causing the musical clarity to suffer. Male
voices were underpowered, and the overall balance was very percussion heavy.
Reservations aside, some memorable performances were heard here. Treble Joseph
Hagley may have looked a little terrified at the outset but sang well and shows
promise; Katherine Gregory was again on top form; Andrew Wyatt’s organ playing
was exceptional and some fine harp playing from Gabriella dall’Olio brought
tenderness and repose to the work.
By total contrast, the final offering of the evening was a
romantic lightweight, Hubert Parry’s ‘Hear My Words, Ye People’. Stirring organ
lines were brought into sharp relief by Andrew Wyatt, supporting some joyous
singing from the whole choir, with added solos from baritone Alex Bower-Brown
and the chamber soloists Sam Lyne-Hall (bass), Alex Davison (tenor), Celia
Stoddart Hunkin (alto) and Katherine Gregory (soprano). But though convincingly
performed, coming after the harmonic riches of the Vaughan Williams, the shimmering
colours of the Rutter and the rhythmic intensity of the Bernstein, I think the
programme would have been tighter and stronger without this piece. It sat somewhat
out of context with the otherwise inventive programming, sending us on our way
with a closing chorus that could have been lifted directly from the Victorian
hymnal and a melody uncomfortably close to ‘Happy Birthday to You’.
The Three Spires’ next concert will be on 16th
November, devoted entirely to Elgar’s Dream of Gerontius. The choir is still
seeking more male voices and if you think you might be interested in joining,
please email membersthreespires@googlemail.com.
Chris
Best 26/07/24
Chris Best is a Cornwall based composer
and writer. More information can be found at www.chrisbestmusic.com
THREE SPIRES CONCERT REVIEW: BACH MASS IN B MINOR
On Saturday 23rd March an expectant crowd returned to Truro cathedral to witness James
Anderson-Besant take the podium for the second time as the newly appointed conductor of
the Three Spires Singers and Orchestra. Joining him on stage were soloists Helena Moore
(soprano), Alasdair Austin (alto), Jack Granby (tenor) and Thomas Butler (bass) to perform J
S Bach’s Mass in B Minor, a work not heard in the cathedral since 2018.
The lead line-up was something of an alumni reunion, both conductor and soloists (Jack
Granby aside) having recently studied together or known each other at Cambridge
University.
From the very first bar it became apparent what a tight rein the conductor was holding on the choir: accents, dynamics and diction were all razor-sharp and on point, allowing even
the densest counterpoint to bite through the cathedral’s lush but unforgiving reverberation.
All four soloists were well-matched, if at times the soprano and tenor lost some power at
the end of phrases (and, being sat at the front, I did wonder how satisfactorily the sound
was finding its way to the back of the hall). Alto Alasdair Austin delivered a particularly
spectacular sound, with a magical purity of tone, precision of pitch (never hidden beneath
unwarranted vibrato), lightness of delivery and crisp enunciation.
The Gloria was taken at lightning speed but remained effective and controlled. Beautiful
chamber moments surfaced successively - soprano with solo violin (leader Nick Whiting),
tenor with solo flute (Karen Green) and alto with solo oboe (Tamsin Robinson). Finally, with
the Gloria approaching its close, bass soloist Thomas Butler entered into dialogue with a
fiendishly difficult French horn solo, impressively executed by Jaqueline Kershaw. By the
final ‘Cum sancto spiritu’, James Anderson-Besant had the choir all but rushed of its feet,
which inevitably sacrificed some detail at the expense of excitement, though sopranos held
their own admirably.
The second half got off to a slightly rocky start but settled in time for the soprano/alto duet
‘Et in unum Dominum Jesum Christum’, a lovely touch here being the close register between
the two parts, allowing the alto’s line at times to rise above the soprano’s – a most pleasing
sound from Helena and Alasdair.
The choir followed with ‘Et incarnatus est de Spiritu Sanctus’, one of the work’s most
tortuous passages that caused a few intonation issues, male voices tending to drift slightly
flat. With so much going on, and being placed so far behind the instrumentalists, the choir
doubtless struggled at times to hear the full orchestral texture.
The chamber-like mood returned with a continuo of cello (Barbara Degener) and bassoon
(Sam Gurney) supporting Thomas Butler’s bass solo, the choir then taking us to the Sanctus,
with its soaring brass opening. The mood then lightened for a fragile and tender solo from
tenor Jack Granby, whose voice well suited this chamber-like scoring, before the choir
closed the movement with their exclamatory hosannas.
And so we arrived at the last part of this extraordinary work, the Agnus Dei: a perfect
marriage between solo flute and Alasdair Austin’s angelic voice, from which emerged the
hushed tones of the choir’s profoundly moving ‘Dona nobis pacem’ to end the work.
The concert was another clear success for conductor James Anderson-Besant, for the
singers, for the orchestra and for the soloists. But the choir could certainly do with more
male voices. If you think you might be interested in joining, please email
membersthreespires@googlemail.com. And do make a note in your diary of their next
concert on 6 th July, when works will include Rutter’s Requiem, Bernstein’s Chichester
Psalms, Vaughan Williams’ Five Mystical Songs and Parry’s Hear My Words, Ye People.
Another concert not to be missed.
Chris Best 21/04/24
Chris Best is a Cornwall based composer and writer. More information can be found at
99www.chrisbestmusic.com
Three Spires Concert Saturday 8th July 2023: Bach Cantata no 80, Ein Feste Burg, Mozart Clarinet Concerto & Scarlatti St Cecilia Mass
While the Three Spires Singers have always striven to
feature top class soloists, the concert on 8th July of works by
Scarlatti, Mozart and Bach surpassed itself with a particular wealth of young
talent: Jacob Perry performing the solo part in Mozart’s Clarinet Concerto,
with Katherine Gregory, Hannah Dienes-Williams, Tom Lilburn, Louis Watkins and
Simon Grant fronting the choir and orchestra for Scarlatti’s St Cecilia Mass
and Bach’s Cantata no. 80, Ein Feste Burg.
Taking the podium for the first time, guest conductor
Patrick Bailey steered the ship with clarity and authority. Though the
programme had been decided in advance by Christopher Gray before his departure,
Patrick embraced the repertoire with enthusiasm and vision both in performance
and during the course of choir and orchestral rehearsals.
The concert opened with the Bach Cantata. At once Patrick stamped
his mark on proceedings with some unorthodox performer choreography. After the
choir’s opening chorus, bass soloist Simon Grant adopted his standard position
to the front left of the conductor for the ensuing duet while soprano Katherine
Gregory’s divine voice emerged unseen from behind the string section, her
presence only revealed via the TV monitor. She then processed forward through
the players for the recitative that followed.
Orchestral forces were stripped back for this work to
chamber size, ably supported by basso continuo of solo cello (Danielle Jones)
and chamber organ and harpsichord (Paul Comeau). Other chamber groupings
followed: solo violin (leader Philip Montgomery-Smith) and oboe (Tamsin
Robinson) joining alto Tom Lilburn and tenor Louis Watkins for the duet ‘Wie
selig sind doch sie’. The choreography again worked its magic here - Tamsin
somehow appearing at the leader’s side before slipping away again for the final
chorale.
All singers gave strong performances in this piece, with
well controlled phrasing, pristine vibrato and razor-sharp diction. The male alto
occasionally struggled to balance the more penetrating tenor voice and the bass
could not quite achieve the expressive levels of his fellow singers. The
outstanding voice among the group, Katherine Gregory seemed totally attuned
both to the Baroque style and to the acoustics and scale of the building. The
choir took a moment to settle into the work, but easily cut through the reduced
orchestral forces, though the difficult acoustic tended to leave them slightly
behind the beat for much of the time, something that in the past Christopher
Gray had largely managed to address.
Mozart’s Clarinet Concerto in A Major completed the first
half of the evening. Soloist Jacob Perry gave an exceptional performance, his
tone full and rounded, his entries perfectly controlled and his phrasing deeply
considered and artfully rendered. Music, soloist, orchestra and space united
here to produce a magical experience. Perry clearly took the utmost delight in
live playing, his presence at times verging on the theatrical as his
expressions captured every nuance of the music, both when playing and when
awaiting his next entry. In response, the orchestra gave an assured performance
of this no doubt tried, tested and much-loved work.
The concert’s second half was taken up with just one work,
Alessandro Scarlatti’s little known St Cecilia Mass. This is arguably a somewhat
problematic piece, with few opportunities for the choir to engage in any
extended singing and little in the way of memorable material or dynamic
contrast. Patrick Bailey managed nonetheless to bring a sense of excitement to
the work by pushing the tempi changes and emphasising the shifts of texture. It
also introduced us to the last of the soloists: second soprano Hannah
Dienes-Williams. Her voice was characterful, though less powerful than that of fellow
soprano Katherine Gregory, the balance therefore working better when she had
the top line. Tom Lilburn’s alto voice sat much more comfortably within this work’s
five-part voicing than within the four-part Bach; it worked especially well
when set simply against cello. The first chance the choir had to shine came at
the close of the Gloria with the ‘Cum Sancto Spiritu’. From here, the work
passes through some intricate interchanges between the soloists in the Credo,
leading to an angelic, beautifully sung choir Amen before the Sanctus. For many
composers, the Sanctus, like the Gloria before it, is an opportunity to add
weight and brilliance to a scoring of the mass. For Scarlatti, it becomes more
a continued winding down towards the closing Agnus Dei, giving a quiet,
considered close to the evening’s music-making.
Patrick Bailey now passes the baton over to new Musical
Director James Anderson-Besant, who will present more Mozart and Bach over the
coming months, the next Three Spires concert being on Saturday 18th
November with Bach’s Magnificat and Mozart’s Horn Concerto and Requiem.
Chris
Best 28/07/23
Chris Best is a Cornwall based
composer and writer. More information can be found at www.chrisbestmusic.com
Click on the links for a selection of reviews from earlier concerts.
Review of Christopher Gray's final concert with Three Spires Singers
Graham Fitkin, Humphry Davy The Age of Aspiration
( Ist performance)
Poulenc Gloria,
Ravel Piano Concerto
Elgar, The Kingdom concert
Kingdom review Nov 2019.docx
Bach, Handel, Buxtehude, July 2019
Bach Handel and Buxtehude.docx
Prokovief, Rutter and Vaughan Williams Concert
Prokovief Rutter Vaughan Williams.docx
Review of WWI Centenary Concert
WWI Centenary Concert review.pdf
Bach: Mass in B Minor concert
2018 March Bach B Minor Mass.pdf
Dvorak and Schumann, November 2017
Stabat Mater Nov 2017 review.pdf
Mendelsohn Elijah, April 2017- a joint concert with Truro Choral Society
Philip Buttall TSS TCS Elijah
Handel Messiah, December 2106 - we were joined on this occasion by choristers from Truro School Chamber Choir
Rachel Beaumont: Messiah
Brahms German Requiem, July 2016
Philip Buttall: Brahms Requiem
Finzi, Tchaikovsky, Elgar and Mendelssohn, November 2016
Philip Buttall: Finzi and others
Elgar The Kingdom,with Truro Choral Society, April 2014
Judith Whitehouse: Elgar The Kingdom
Russell Pascoe, Secular Requiem; Strauss, Four Last Songs March 2013
Judith Whitehouse: Russell Pascoe Secular Requiem